12 April 2007 @ 06:01 pm
PET FOOD - Bad And Good  
** EDIT: Anonymous may post, but all anonymous will be screened to prevent spam showing up **

** EDIT #2: See added notes on the bottom **

For those who have been living under a rock :) there have been cases of tainted pet foods from a company called Menu Foods. The affected pet foods have been sold in both the USA and, they recently discovered, also in Canada.

You can see their press releases here.

Essentially, wheat gluten has been tainted with a chemical called Melamine - yes, that stuff often used in plastics - which has resulted in health problems such as kidney failure in both cats and dogs - though cats are more susceptible to this problem (I don't know specifically why, but my guess is that their smaller size, and thus smaller kidney size to begin with, might have something to do with it.)

The reason I'm tagging this as an educational post is that I want to inform people that cats in particular really should NOT be eating wheat and rice products ANYWAY - they are carnivores by nature and genetics. Why are wheat and rice products often sold in cat foods? I would imagine that it's due to it being an inexpensive filler in comparison to using quality meats.

Some folks are turning to raw feeding - which, by itself, isn't a bad thing per se, but you need to understand nutritional requirements for the pet(s) in question. Cats have more specific nutritional needs and requirements than dogs - for example, cats need Vitamin A *AS* Vitamin A - they are unable to convert Beta Carotene to Vitamin A since that it something their prey is expected to have already done.

Caveat: I'm a cat person, not a dog person, thus my advice is geared for those who live with cats.

Various veterinary nutritional guides would be of help in determining a good raw food diet, however, since not everyone can slog through medical terminology :) I also recommend the site Holisticat for plain speaking and a large population of people who care deeply for their cats. Unfortunately the Holisticat listserv is no longer existing, however, they do have a forum which I also recommend highly.

(Remember: no vampire chat there :P )

If you can't afford or are otherwise unable to provide a raw diet, I'd like to recommend the food I've been getting for MY kitties: Innova Evo (which, btw, is made for both cats AND dogs...) This is a grain-free pet food that uses human-quality meats and vegetables. And when you open a can of wet food it doesn't smell grocery-store-food vile either. :)

The actual website for the Innova Evo line

Some reviews for Innova Evo:
@ About.com
@ Rateitall.com - Dog food
@ Rateitall.com - Cat/Kitten food

Ratings on Amazon for Innova Evo Cat & Kitten dry kibble:
here, here, and here

Ratings on Amazon for Innova Evo Cat & Kitten Canned:
here, here, and here.

Simaler good reviews for Innova Evo dog food were seen on Amazon as well.


Granted, it's not cheap. But then, quality PEOPLE food isn't cheap either. :) It also can be hard to find, depending on your area.

Here's my trick for getting it at or below list price without having to leave the house: Pet Food Direct. They have an email list service; sign up on their email list, and they send you coupons to your email every few days. Wait for a coupon that's 20% or better, and order Innova Evo through them. They carry both dry AND canned - AND THEY DELIVER - an absolute godsend in shitty weather. :)

The disadvantage of Pet Food Direct is that regardless of what the website hints at, allow up to TWO WEEKS before it arrives at your doorstep, and they typically ship UPS Ground. Plan accordingly - Coupons at 20% or better usually get sent out 1-2/month; usually they run between 10-15% off.

For anything else, always always *always* PRICE COMPARE between local sources and the PFD website. You might find that ordering something else costs 2x as much before shipping, as it would to drive to the other side of town and pick it up from your local store.

Caveat: I don't know if Pet Food Direct ships outside of the USA - call or email them to find out. Shipping will probably be proportionately larger to other countries if they do, as they are USA based.

** Edit #2: [info]memoryanddream mentioned Wellness brand has a no-grain alternative called Core, so there's at least two no-grain/rice/barley options out there now. **
 
 
( Read 4 riddles — Post a new comment )
: : miss m : :: Mika and Gracie[info]memoryanddream on April 18th, 2007 03:20 pm (UTC)
Another couple to check out?

Blue Buffalo - http://bluebuff.com/

Wellness - http://www.oldmotherhubbard.com/wellness/

My girls eat these and they're really good foods.
Doctor Bone Blight (SphynxCatVP): Thoughtful -- Hmmm[info]sphynxcatvp on April 18th, 2007 07:27 pm (UTC)
I'm aware of them, but for me the problem is that they both use grains, rice and/or barleys as one of their chief ingredients.

IMO, With cats being obligate carnivores, g/r/b's should not be among the chief ingredients in their food. (Research what zoos feed to their big cats and you'll see what I mean. There's also a link here that you might find interesting - that vet works with zoo and domestic animals.)

These are better options than things like Iams or grocery store cat food, but they're just not something I would consider for my kitties because of the g/r/b's.

: : miss m : :: mika eating the plant[info]memoryanddream on April 18th, 2007 08:16 pm (UTC)
Wellness offers a line called "Core" which has no grains. It was too rich for my cats to digest properly but it's a raw food alternative: http://www.oldmotherhubbard.com/wellness/cat_wellness_dry_core.html

I am 100% satisfied with my food choices for them. I have done extensive research on the subject and I stand by the two brands. No wheat, no corn, no soy - I think their approach is good and my girls greatly enjoy the products as well.
Doctor Bone Blight (SphynxCatVP): Pleased[info]sphynxcatvp on April 18th, 2007 08:40 pm (UTC)
Hmmm, I like the look of "Core" - I'll add that to my list.

If the others work for you, that's cool... I used an organic kitten food that had grains in it for a number of years, but after all the cancers I've dealt with lately (between cats and other family members) I'm just more paranoid than usual about what's in the foods we all eat - regardless of pet food recalls.